Surety, Product

SURETY OUTLOOK DIGEST NO. 3: The Legacy Tax Behind Surety’s ROI Problem

Tinubu Surety
November 19, 2026

77% of Surety carriers say difficulty quantifying ROI holds back modernization. It’s the most cited barrier in Surety Outlook 2026: Tech & Ops Benchmarks, Everest Group’s survey of North American Surety carriers and brokers.

It’s easy to read that as a measurement problem, but the survey points to something more basic underneath: legacy systems. Carriers spend 69% of their technology budget on the systems they already run: 39% just keeping them running, and 30% on upgrades. Just 27% goes to new technology such as AI, APIs and broker portals.

Call it the legacy tax. It feeds a loop. With most of the budget tied up in existing technology, there’s little left to build the capabilities that would show a return. Without that return, the budget stays where it is.

“That isn’t a technology budget. It’s a maintenance bill with some upgrades attached,” says Heather McCracken, Senior Product Manager at Tinubu. “One of the problems is that the modernization you can’t fund is what would make the maintenance cheaper.”

Why the Return Is Hard to See

The cost of legacy systems doesn’t stay in the IT budget. No capability in the survey runs primarily on modern, configurable technology at a majority of carriers. Submission intake and renewals are each primarily modern for only 16%. 26% of carriers still handle renewals and endorsements mostly by hand.

“Carriers aren’t only paying to maintain legacy systems. They’re paying people to work around them,” McCracken says. “The form library someone keeps current by hand, the renewal that touches three systems. None of that shows up in the 39%.”

When much of the cost sits in workarounds no one tracks, the savings from removing them are just as hard to see. And the situation drains the means to fix it: 62% of carriers say they lack the internal resources to build modern capabilities, and 54% cite the high cost of ownership and implementation.

Breaking the Legacy Loop, One Capability at a Time

Breaking the loop doesn’t take a bigger budget, or a full platform replacement whose payoff could be years away and difficult to justify in the short term. Everest Group finds that modernizing one capability at a time, while keeping core platforms that still work, costs less and can be easier to implement than replacing the core end to end. And because each change is small and specific, the return is easier to measure.

As a start, McCracken suggests looking for that return in the handoffs, inside the carrier as well as outside it. “Modernize the handoffs: agent to carrier, underwriter to issuance, carrier to obligee, and the whole chain speeds up, even if the core system behind it is 20 years old,” she says.

What Everest Group Recommends

For carriers: modernize at the capability level. Prioritize high-friction workflows, and keep core platforms where replacing them wouldn’t create a clear operating benefit.

  • What to track: year-on-year growth in the share of technology spend going to new capabilities, against an industry baseline where 69% goes to maintaining and enhancing existing systems, and the resulting drop in processing time and manual effort.

For brokers: improve data quality at the point of submission. Standardize and enrich submission data earlier in the workflow, so less of it has to be corrected downstream.

  • What to track: shorter new-client turnaround, where 54% of brokers currently report six days or more, as cleaner data cuts the time lost before underwriting starts.

The legacy tax won’t vanish in one budget cycle. But every capability carriers modernize brings the bill down, and makes the return easier to see.

How does your technology spend compare with your peers’? The full Surety Outlook 2026: Tech & Ops Benchmarks report breaks down where carriers and brokers stand, with Everest Group’s recommendations for each.

[Download the report]

 

 

More from Tinubu